Zain: Worth vs Value*

August 21, 2009 by Guest Contribution

By Osama:

I still haven’t met anyone who gets ripped off by Zain more than I do. Honestly, I barely talk on the phone and have my blackberry service fee, therefore, I should be paying just about KD20/month. But on every 11th day of the month, I get the most beautiful morning message from Zain: Dear customer pay KD65 or else. And happily I go to the Zain website month after month and pay.

WHY? Is the service Zain provides worth more than the services of other Telecom companies? No, however, with Zain I get my phone service, my internet service, my bb service, I use their one network when I’m travelling, and I know that a portion of my bills will be spent on greater causes. Do I get that with other telecom companies? No. For that reason: I choose Zain.

I’m really sick and tired of people who play around with financial models and fictional numbers, try to be smart and evaluate Zain on previous performance. Frankly, I still haven’t met a person whose an expert on the economic stability of every single one of the 24 countries Zain operates in neither have I met a person with a crystal ball that can predict the future . Nevertheless, I believe in real numbers and I believe in evaluating the competition. I know that  Zain is trading at a very high multiple of 7.9X EV/EBITDA, but still recommend people to buy it either for short term gains (sell at KD1.800) or long term capital appreciation with a company that has shown that it sets very high standards and reaches them. Yes, they play around with the balance sheet but GAAP asset valuation methods changed in March, hence, if auditors believe that the financials fairly reflect the company’s current state then that’s the end of the story.

Compared to its regional peers, Zain is way ahead. It is perfectly positioned in its home market, secured the Levant, progressing in Iraq, blossoming in Saudi, and breaking records in Africa. Most of it markets have dense bottomed population pyramids, economic growth, and specifically Africa has very low penetration rates. Currency swings, high interest payments, and so on will naturally have an effect on the company’s bottom line. However, Zain is building relations with the world (a wonderful world).

I have great trust in Zain’s management and wouldn’t be surprised if Zain were to make a 7X oversubscribed bond offering and reschedule their debt. In my view of the Telecom industry, no company can increase their customer base more than Zain, MTN, and Bharti Airtel. These three companies’ operations add value to societies and to others. Hence, in a time where liquidity is very apparent in banks around the world and investments are made based on a company’s ability to  provide solid cash flow; everyone wants a bite. So if Mr. Khorafi wants to sell his stake, there are many willing buyers. The remaining question is: At what cost?

In my view, at a cost much higher than what many believe the company is worth or at least double that.

P.S. I’m not expecting a cash sale. What I’m expecting is a share swap which will give Zain an even more steady income stream and add more value. But for those of you who love the quick buck, sell the stock the day you see high value and its at limit up (KD1.800).  Then, buyback at  around KD1.400. Try to time it, but if you get caught its your fault. What I advise is long term investing in this company even at current prices.

* This article is a guest contributor article. Further, it does not represent the views of Alpha Dinar.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

8 Responses to “Zain: Worth vs Value*”

  1. a.lateef says:

    i think you are very optimistic on zain , i dont think this stock is a good for long term investment due to the problems they facing in iraq and africa even in kuwait they will loss a big share of customers when the government allowed to transfer your mobile numbers between companies with out changing your number .

    [Reply]

  2. peteyb says:

    its customary to have a bit of background on such a piece that relies heavily on opinion coupled with facts. there’s nothing wrong with doing so but either have the persons full name (so that we can google them) or a reliable description of their background.

    otherwise, i am sorry to say, this post is not worth the bits it is magnetized on.

    [Reply]

  3. keynesian09 says:

    a.lateef:
    I totally agree with you. In fact, I will be posting an article tomorrow detailing why Zain is a SCREAMING SELL.

    peteyb:
    Please note that this is NOT an article by alpha dinar’s main contributors. Instead, it is a guest submitted article. As you may have noticed, we have been passionate advocates of selling Zain. We got an emailed article contribution from a reader with an opposite point of view. Further, we were morally and professionally obligated to post it. I will be posting a piece about Zain tmrw that I hope you’like. Thanks for your objective critique!

    [Reply]

  4. dxb kola says:

    peteyb:
    why does it matter who’s offering the opinion on the company or stock?

    I know who Ben Bernanke is and I definitely know who Tim Geithner is. Their backgrounds are as clear as day to most people interested in who they are. Same goes for Hank Paulson.
    Guess what? Knowing who they are made has made no an iota of a difference in anyone’s judgement of the actions they have taken and the things they have stated.
    We all know who Dick Fuld is? Angelo Mozzilo of Country Wide? Ken Lewis? CNBC’s Cramer? Colin Powell pre Iraq Invasion?
    But let’s not get into that.
    If the guest contributor backs his/her opinions with facts and evidence that should be more than enough for us decide whether to take the piece seriously or not.
    Have you watched any Geithner/Bernanke/Paulson testimonies over the past 2 years to Congress.
    They appear downright embarassing and obtuse most of the time.
    I really don’t get your comment, peteyb.
    You’ll really enjoy blogoronomy then. We focus on making it as childish as possible over there!

    [Reply]

  5. dxb kola says:

    May I add to the last comment that I believe it is immeasurably better to get an opinion or view from a person of unimportance. I would rather listen to someone with no vested interests and with and of no authority express an opinion on whatever topic.
    Big philosophers have eternally argued for the importance of analysing an argument, and of discarding information about who is making that argument.

    [Reply]

  6. keynesian09 says:

    dxb kola:

    Well said. I agree.

    [Reply]

  7. abnehmen says:

    … [Trackback]…

    [...] Read More: alphadinar.com/2009/08/21/zain-worth-vs-value/ [...]…

  8. Cinema Bienne…

    [...]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]…

Leave a Reply